Money – Sex Change Case Study (Genetics) |
[A] |
Prove that nurture determined gender identity, not nature. |
[P] |
- Longitudinal study on David Reimer.
- David Reimer was a boy who lost his penis while a circumcision accident.
- Money suggested David’s parents to give him a sex change.
- He did not reveal his true motive was to prove that nurture determines gender identity, not nature.
|
[F] |
- When David grew up, he displayed masculine behaviour.
- Causing problems in school with his peers.
|
[C] |
- Proves the psychosexual development is determined by chromosomes and hormones.
|
[E] |
- Ethical guidelines: Unethical
- A lot of deception and uninformed consent.
- No protection from physical and mental harm.
- No rights of withdrawal.
- Milton Diamond was not convinced, he examined the role of hormones on the developing fetus.
- Suggesting that psychosexual development is not determined by genitalia or upbringing, but rather chromosomes and hormones.
|
Seligman – Learned Helplessness Dog Study (Depression) |
[A] |
Prove that Learned Helplessness can lead to depression. |
[P] |
- A dog was trapped in an enclosed area where the floor was lined with electrodes.
- The experimenter would activate the electrode once in a while.
- The dog would jump over a low wall to the other side of the enclosed area where no electrodes were on the floor.
- The experimenter raised the wall slowly until it was too high for the dog to jump over.
- Then after a few trials, the experimenter lowered the wall again.
|
[F] |
- The dog gave the high wall a few attempts.
- But after knowing that it is impossible to jump across, the dog gave up and let itself get electrocuted.
- When the walls were lowered again, the dog did not attempt to jump across.
|
[C] |
- The dog learnt that he is incapable of jumping across.
- Learn that its are helpless therefore lowering its self esteem.
|
[E] |
- Low in ecological validity, lab experiment.
- Controlled, no confounding variable.
- Animal experiment can provide insight into human behaviour.
- Unethical, participants did not have rights to withdraw.
- Induced fear and depression into participants.
|