Using one or more examples, explain “emic” and “etic” concepts. (8)
Explain (8) – Detailed account including reasons or causes.
Etic – Cross-culture approach
- Tackles culture with one general approach.
World Health Organisation Study on Depression |
[A] |
A study of diagnosis and classification of depression in Switzerland, Canada, Japan and Iran. |
[P] |
- 576 patients were studied
- Used a standard diagnosis system for the four countries
|
[F] |
- 40% of patients displayed symptoms that were not on the classification system.
|
[C] |
- Diagnosis and classification system need an Emic (Culture specific) approach because socially acceptable norms are different in different cultures.
|
Emic – Cultural specific approach
- Tackles culture specifically and individually.
Bond and Smith – Asch’s Paradigm with different cultures (Conformity/Culture) |
Experiment brief |
- Meta-analysis of 133 Asch's Paradigm study in 17 different countries around the world.
|
[F] |
- Individualist societies tend to have a lower rate of conformity (e.g. US, UK, France)
- Collectivist societies tend to have a higher rate of conformity (e.g. Hong Kong, Fiji, Brazil)
|
[C] |
- Displayed the effect of culture on conformity.
|
[E] |
- Emic approach: took care of the cultural differences around the world individually
- Evaluative points of Asch's Paradigm apply.
|